The latest album from Phish, titled Joy, was released last Tuesday. Though it had been leaked to the internet and then posted for streaming from Phish’s MySpace page a few weeks prior, I had waited until the official release to listen to the album in full. Overall, I would say that as a studio album, this is one of the band’s strongest. Steve Lillywhite’s production is impeccable and each song stands on its own. The one complaint is that the album isn’t really cohesive. Considering it’s from Phish, I’m not overly upset by that. They most definitely aren’t known for their studio work. From the perspective of each individual song, it’s their strongest album, but as a whole, the last album Lillywhite produced for them, Billy Breathes, is better.
The album opens with “Backwards Down the Number Line” a song written from a poem Tom Marshall had sent to Trey. The song is probably the poppiest song on the album, but not in a bad way. It’s a well written song with great lyrics. Like most Phish songs, it’s better live than on the album, but it certainly doesn’t make me think of Trey’s Shine, an album known for being all catchy pop music and one of Trey’s worst musical works.
The second song on the album, “Stealing Time from the Faulty Plan”, is a nice psychedelic rock song that really showcases the “new” Phish. The guitar riffs and lyrics are a bit darker and contrast nicely with the easy listening opening track.
Up next is a song Trey had written for his sister who recently passed away after a battle with cancer. The title track of the album is a beautiful uplifting ballad, slowing down the music for a bit.
The fourth track is a Mike song called “Sugar Shack”. This is a fun funky tune that brings visions of New Orleans (at least to me). It has a hint of a reggae beat. It’s a classic Mike tune that goes down as one of his best.
In the fifth spot is the laid back groove of “Ocelot”. This was a much anticipated song for me. It’s a great easy listening song with a catchy tune, but by no means poppy. The laid back grooves make this a perfect song for a lazy summer Sunday afternoon.
Following “Ocelot” is probably my least favorite song of the album, “Kill Devil Falls”, a straight up rocker. The song itself is pretty good, but it’s almost out of place on the album. The initial guitar riff makes me want the song to be a bit faster and harder rocking than it is. It could be a great 60’s surf rock song, but it’s just a tad too slow.
The next song, “Light”, has an intro that they can extend and practically turn into its own jam when they play it live. The song is one of the best songs on the album. It’s got a nice slow build from the ambient intro into a powerful tune, much in the same style as “Piper”, though the building intro isn’t as long. It’s a nice rocking song, similar to some of Trey’s later solo work from Bar 17 or 18 Steps.
“I Been Around” is a short bluesy Page song that provides a nice little interlude before the epic 13 minute composition of “Time Turns Elastic”. TTE has become known as a set killer when they play it live. While it may someday make a great closer for the first set of a show, only the ending of the song is really worth hearing live. It’s much better on the album than live. Though I did also buy the album Time Turns Elastic with the 30 minute classical composition written with Don Hart and loved it that way, the song just doesn’t pop coming from Phish. I think if they can really work out some better improv with it and sway from playing the exact composition for much of the song, it can be awesome live. Until then, it’s a long bathroom break.
Closing out the album is “Twenty Years Later”, which is a retrospective on life. It’s a slow rocker, again showing some of Trey’s newer writing similar to some of the stuff off Bar 17.
Overall, the album is one of their strongest, only beat out by Billy Breathes for both production and cohesiveness. While Rift is always a fan favorite, the production quality of this album is worlds away. I’d rank Phish’s studio albums something like this:
- Billy Breathes
- Joy
- Rift
- Story of the Ghost
- Picture of Nectar
- Junta
- Farmhouse
- Hoist
- Round Room
- Lawn Boy
- Undermind
We’ll see what happens when I receive my Joy box with the Party Time album included. I also didn’t include the Siket Disc or the White Tape in my list, though the White Tape would probably fall near the bottom and the Siket Disc is more ambient jamming than a real studio album.
Recent Comments